Willis & Associates Family DentistryChurchville · Est. 1950

Tooth pain

Toothache — what to do, when to call.

Tooth pain that won’t settle within a day, or pain that wakes you up at night, almost always means something needs attention. Call us — that’s the short version.

Toothaches come in different flavors, and the kind of pain you have usually tells us what’s wrong. A sharp twinge from cold or sweet foods that fades in a few seconds often points to a cavity or exposed root surface. A dull constant ache that builds over hours can suggest an inflamed pulp — the nerve and blood vessel inside the tooth. Throbbing pain that wakes you up, or pain plus visible swelling, usually means infection and needs urgent treatment.

What you can do before we see you

Rinse your mouth gently with warm salt water — about a teaspoon of salt in eight ounces of warm water. It won’t fix the underlying problem, but it cleans the area and often eases the pressure briefly. An over-the-counter pain reliever — ibuprofen if you can tolerate it, acetaminophen otherwise — helps most moderate tooth pain.

A cold compress against the outside of your face can dull the ache. Avoid putting heat on the area, and avoid putting aspirin directly on the gum — it can chemically burn the tissue. Floss around the painful tooth gently, in case there’s a piece of food trapped between teeth that’s creating pressure. (More often than people expect, that’s the entire cause.)

When to call

Call us at 540-337-6004 if any of the following apply:

  • The pain has lasted more than 24 hours
  • The pain wakes you up at night or keeps you from eating
  • You can see or feel swelling around the tooth or in your face
  • You notice a pimple-like bump on the gum near the tooth
  • The tooth feels loose or has changed position
  • You have a fever along with the tooth pain

What to expect at the appointment

When you walk in, our front desk gets you settled and into a treatment room quickly — we don’t leave anyone with significant pain sitting in a waiting room. Dr. Agrawal listens to your description of the pain, takes a careful look at the tooth, and uses a small targeted X-ray if it’s needed. We’ll get the tooth numb before any treatment starts so you’re comfortable through the exam itself.

From there, the path forward depends on the cause. A simple cavity gets filled the same day. An inflamed nerve typically needs root canal therapy — performed in our office, comfortably, with sedation available. An infection gets drained and antibiotics started immediately, with follow-up treatment scheduled to address whatever caused it.

Comfort options if you’re anxious

For patients who are nervous about a same-day visit — especially one involving an injection or a longer procedure — we offer nitrous oxide (the gentle calming gas you breathe through a small mask) and oral sedation for deeper relaxation. Both let you stay awake but considerably more at ease. Let our front desk know when you call that you’d like comfort options on the table, and we’ll plan accordingly.

Antibiotics and pain medication — what we prescribe

When there’s a clear infection (swelling, fever, a draining bump on the gum), we usually start a short course of antibiotics — most often amoxicillin for 5 to 7 days — while we treat the source. For pain control after a procedure, ibuprofen alternated with acetaminophen handles most dental pain remarkably well. Stronger prescriptions are reserved for situations where they’re genuinely needed, and we’ll talk you through the plan before you leave.

When toothache becomes an ER situation

Most dental pain belongs in a dental chair — but a small fraction of cases need a hospital. If your face is swelling toward your eye or down your neck, if you’re having trouble swallowing or breathing, or if you have a fever above 101 along with the tooth pain, go to the nearest emergency room. Augusta Health in Fishersville is the closest for most of western Augusta County. Then call us first thing the next morning so we can plan the dental side of the treatment.

Whatever we find, you’ll leave the office on Scenic Hwy with a clear plan and significant relief. Most toothaches can be resolved in one or two visits.

Frequently asked

Toothaches — common questions.

How fast can you actually see me from Buffalo Gap or Deerfield?

If you call us early in the day during clinical hours, we hold space for same-day emergencies. From Buffalo Gap, Deerfield, Middlebrook, or anywhere along the US-250 corridor, you can usually be in our chair within an hour of your call. Tell our front desk the pain level and any swelling — that helps us prioritize how quickly to fit you in.

What sedation or comfort options do you offer for emergency visits?

Nitrous oxide is available for most appointments and takes the edge off if you’re anxious. For more involved work like a same-day root canal, we also offer oral sedation that lets you stay calm and relaxed throughout. We’ll talk through what fits your medical history and the procedure ahead — comfort is part of the plan, not an add-on.

Will you prescribe antibiotics or painkillers?

When there’s clear evidence of infection (swelling, fever, a draining bump on the gum), we typically start antibiotics — usually amoxicillin for 5 to 7 days — alongside the treatment that addresses the source. For pain, we generally recommend over-the-counter ibuprofen and acetaminophen used together; that combination is remarkably effective for dental pain. Stronger prescriptions are reserved for cases where they’re genuinely needed.

When should I go to the ER instead of waiting for the office to open?

Go to the emergency room or urgent care if you have facial swelling that’s spreading toward your eye or down your neck, difficulty breathing or swallowing, a fever above 101 along with your tooth pain, or uncontrolled bleeding. Those are signs the infection has moved beyond what a dental office can manage. Then call us first thing the next morning to plan the dental side of treatment.

What will my visit look like once I’m in the chair?

Dr. Agrawal starts with a careful look at the painful tooth and a small X-ray if it’s needed. From there, the path depends on what we find. A simple cavity gets numbed and filled at the same visit. An inflamed nerve usually means a root canal, often the same day. An infection gets drained and antibiotics started immediately. Whatever the cause, you leave with a clear plan and significant relief.

Do I need to be a current patient to come in for a toothache?

No. We welcome new patients in pain — that’s often how a long relationship with this office starts. Bring a photo ID, your insurance card if you have one, and a list of any medications you take. The new-patient paperwork can be filled in either online before you arrive or at the front desk; we won’t make you wait through forms while you’re hurting.

A tooth hurts? Let’s get you out of pain.

Same-day appointments are available during clinical hours.